Reviews
Dealer Reviews
Independent dealer comparisons built on each dealer's published policies, BBB and Trustpilot records, and live price tracking for six dealers. No sponsored placements.
Top Dealers
| Dealer | Rating | Minimum | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|
| APMEX Prices not tracked | 4.2 | None | Review |
| JM Bullion | 4.2 | None | Review |
| Money Metals Exchange Prices not tracked | 4.2 | None | Review |
| Monument Metals | 4.1 | None | Review |
| BOLD Precious Metals Prices not tracked | 3.9 | None | Review |
| Silver Gold Bull Prices not tracked | 3.9 | None | Review |
| Bullion Exchanges Prices not tracked | 3.8 | None | Review |
| Golden Eagle Coins | 3.8 | None | Review |
| SD Bullion Prices not tracked | 3.8 | None | Review |
| Kitco | 3.7 | $5,000 | Review |
| BGASC Prices not tracked | 3.5 | None | Review |
| Hero Bullion | 3.5 | None | Review |
| Gainesville Coins | 1.9 | None | Review |
Our Methodology
Every dealer in our rankings is evaluated against the same scoring framework. We track prices on benchmark gold and silver products for the dealers our tracker can read, pulling live prices every 15 minutes where a dealer exposes a pricing endpoint and hourly where a browser read is needed. Our tracker cannot currently read seven dealers' sites; they are marked "prices not tracked" and we do not estimate their premiums.
We evaluate each dealer's published shipping, payment, return and buyback policies, and read its BBB profile and Trustpilot page.
Composite ratings are re-scored on a quarterly cadence. We do not currently score price. We accept no payment for placement or favorable reviews.
Dealer Comparisons
Head-to-Head Dealer Comparisons
- APMEX vs JM Bullion: two of the largest US dealers compared.
- APMEX vs SD Bullion: selection leader versus price match guarantee.
- APMEX vs Hero Bullion: established giant versus newer challenger.
- JM Bullion vs SD Bullion: price-focused comparison.
- SD Bullion vs Hero Bullion: two dealers aimed at cost-conscious stackers.
- SD Bullion vs Money Metals: price match guarantee versus auto-invest specialist.
- Hero Bullion vs JM Bullion: newer disruptor versus polished veteran.
- Monument Metals vs JM Bullion: silver specialist versus all-around dealer.
- Monument Metals vs SD Bullion: two no-minimum dealers face off.
- Money Metals vs JM Bullion: DCA specialist versus polished shopping experience.
- Silver Gold Bull vs JM Bullion: Canadian versus US operations.
- BOLD vs Hero Bullion: two newer brands.
- Bullion Exchanges vs JM Bullion: NYC selection versus polished UX.
- Golden Eagle Coins vs APMEX: numismatic specialist versus full-catalog dealer.
Best Dealer By Product
- Best place to buy Gold Eagles
- Best place to buy Silver Eagles
- Best place to buy gold bars
- Best place to buy silver bars
- Best place to buy junk silver
- Best place to buy platinum
- Best place to buy fractional gold
By Feature
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you rate online gold dealers?
We score four categories on a 1-5 scale: Reputation (40%), Service and Policies (27%), Transparency (20%) and Selection (13%). Reputation is computed from each dealer's BBB grade, accreditation, Trustpilot score and years in business. We do not currently score price, because we have live price data for only six of the thirteen dealers. See our methodology page for full details.
What is the best online gold dealer?
The best dealer depends on your priorities. APMEX offers the widest selection, and Hero Bullion and Golden Eagle Coins have the lowest free shipping thresholds. For price, compare live quotes on our premium tracker, which reads six dealers directly. Our rankings reflect overall value across all factors.
Are online gold dealers safe?
Reputable online dealers are safe and often more cost-effective than local shops. Look for dealers with established track records, transparent pricing, insured shipping, and buyback guarantees. All dealers in our rankings meet these minimum standards.
How often are dealer ratings updated?
Dealer ratings are re-scored on a quarterly cadence, incorporating premium data, policy changes, and any shifts in BBB or Trustpilot standing. Premium data itself refreshes continuously in the background. Major changes to a dealer's policies, pricing structure, or customer service standing trigger immediate re-evaluation.
Do you earn commissions from dealer referrals?
No. Minted Metal has zero financial relationships with any precious metals dealer or Gold IRA company we review. We do not earn affiliate commissions, referral fees, or any other compensation from the dealers covered on this site. Site revenue comes from affiliate partnerships in adjacent categories such as home safes and security systems. Our reviews are published the same regardless of any commercial relationship.