Dealer Comparison
APMEX vs SD Bullion
The largest online precious metals dealer versus a leaner competitor focused on common bullion. We break down pricing, selection, shipping, and service so you can pick the right dealer for your buying strategy.
Updated November 17, 2026
Verdict
At a Glance
APMEX vs SD Bullion at a Glance
Every fact below comes from the same data that powers our individual APMEX and SD Bullion reviews, so the two pages cannot disagree.
| APMEX | SD Bullion | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 4.2 / 5 | 3.8 / 5 |
| Premium data | Not tracked | Not tracked |
| Minimum order | None | None |
| Free shipping | Orders over $199 | Orders over $199 |
| Payment methods | Check, Wire, Credit card, Crypto, ACH, PayPal | Check, E-check, Wire, Credit card, PayPal, Crypto |
| Buyback program | Yes | Yes |
| BBB rating | A+, accredited | A+, accredited |
| Trustpilot | 4.4 / 5 (10,609+ reviews) | 4.1 / 5 (3,158+ reviews) |
| IRA services | Yes | Yes |
| Founded | 2000 | 2012 |
| Headquarters | Oklahoma City, OK | Fort Worth, TX |
Facts last checked November 17, 2026 against each dealer's published policies, BBB profile and Trustpilot page. Ratings come from our scoring methodology.
Live Premiums
Live Premiums: Who Is Cheaper Today?
Premium over spot is the real price of bullion. The table compares each dealer's current cash or wire price on the five products stackers buy most, against the LBMA spot value of the metal inside.
Our tracker does not currently have live quotes for both dealers on the same product. Where our tracker cannot read a dealer's site, the table shows "not tracked" and we do not publish an estimate. Check that dealer's product page for its current price.
| Product | Spot value | APMEX | SD Bullion | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 oz American Gold Eagle | $4,144.55 | —not tracked | —not tracked | — |
| 1 oz American Silver Eagle | $61.33 | —not tracked | —not tracked | — |
| 1 oz Gold Bar | $4,144.55 | —not tracked | —not tracked | — |
| 1 oz Canadian Gold Maple Leaf | $4,144.55 | —not tracked | —not tracked | — |
| 10 oz Silver Bar | $613.30 | —not tracked | —not tracked | — |
Cash/wire prices read directly from each dealer's site by our premium tracker; spot from the LBMA fix. Snapshot . Card prices run about 4% higher at most dealers. "Not tracked" means our tracker cannot currently read the dealer's site; we do not estimate its prices. How the tracker works.
Overview
How These Dealers Compare
APMEX and SD Bullion represent two fundamentally different approaches to selling precious metals online. APMEX, founded in 2000, built its business on being the everything store for precious metals. Its catalog runs from fractional gold to vintage numismatics and is the broadest of the dealers we review. SD Bullion, launched in 2012, took the opposite path: a lean product catalog focused on common bullion.
The decision between these two dealers comes down to a simple question. Do you want the widest selection and a mature buying platform, or a narrower catalog of common bullion backed by a price match guarantee? Read our full APMEX review and SD Bullion review for in-depth assessments of each.
Pricing Comparison
Pricing
We cannot compare these two dealers on price. We do not currently track APMEX's or SD Bullion's prices because our tracker cannot currently read either site. Check each dealer's product page for the current price of the item you want.
SD Bullion offers a price match guarantee. If a competitor lists an identical in-stock product at a lower price, SD Bullion will match it. APMEX does not offer a formal price match policy.
Product Selection
Product Selection: Where APMEX Dominates
APMEX has the broadest selection of the dealers we review, spanning gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and copper. Rare and collectible coins, certified numismatics, vintage US gold coins, limited-edition mint releases, and fractional gold in every weight from 1/10 oz to 1 oz fill a catalog designed for both investors and collectors.
SD Bullion's catalog is deliberately narrow. Core bullion products are well-represented: gold bars and coins from major refiners, silver bars (1 oz to 100 oz), rounds, sovereign coins, and some platinum. But limited numismatic inventory, few vintage items, and minimal fractional gold options mean that specialized buyers will often need to shop elsewhere.
For the buyer who wants a 1/10 oz gold coin from a specific mint year, an obscure international sovereign, or a certified pre-1933 gold piece, APMEX is the only realistic option between these two. For the buyer who wants 10 oz of generic silver rounds, both dealers stock them.
Website and Ordering
Website and Ordering Experience
APMEX's website reflects more than 25 years of continuous refinement. Filtering by metal type, product category, weight, mint, and price range works reliably. The ability to sort by premium-over-spot is particularly useful for surfacing the best relative value within a category. Search handles both broad queries and specific product lookups. The mobile app adds real-time price alerts and push notifications for price dips.
SD Bullion's website functions adequately but lacks polish. Navigation is workable, product filtering has improved over time, and payment-tiered pricing displays clearly. However, inconsistent product photography, less intuitive search, and a dated visual design create friction, especially for newer buyers who want confidence that they are ordering the right product. Experienced stackers who know exactly what they want will navigate SD Bullion without issues.
Shipping
Shipping and Delivery
Both dealers offer free shipping on orders over $199 with full insurance via USPS, UPS, or FedEx. In-stock items typically ship within 1-3 business days for card payments at both retailers.
APMEX ships from Oklahoma City, providing central US transit times. SD Bullion ships from its fulfillment center near northwest Ohio, which offers fast delivery to the eastern half of the country and standard ground timelines to the West Coast.
Customer Service
Customer Service and Buyback
APMEX offers phone, email, and live chat support.
SD Bullion provides phone and email support. As of November 2026, SD Bullion has 99 complaints filed with the BBB in the last three years and APMEX has 260; those counts are not adjusted for order volume.
Both dealers operate buyback programs. You can lock in a sell price online or by phone at either dealer. Exact pricing depends on the product and market conditions.
Verdict
The Bottom Line
Choose SD Bullion if you buy common bullion products and want a price match guarantee on identical in-stock items. We cannot tell you which dealer is cheaper, so compare the two product pages before you order.
Choose APMEX if you want the widest product selection, a polished website, or access to rare and collectible coins. APMEX's catalog depth is unmatched, and the buying experience is more refined. It suits collectors, IRA investors, and buyers who value convenience.
Both dealers are legitimate and well-established with BBB A+ ratings. For live prices from the dealers we do track, see our premium tracker. Browse all dealer reviews for the full picture.
Trust
Is APMEX Legit? Is SD Bullion Legit?
APMEX was founded in 2000 and operates from Oklahoma City, OK. It holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and is BBB accredited. On Trustpilot it scores 4.4 out of 5 across more than 10,609 reviews. Our tracker cannot currently read its website, so we do not have live prices for it and do not publish an estimate. Read the full APMEX review.
SD Bullion was founded in 2012 and operates from Fort Worth, TX. It holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and is BBB accredited. On Trustpilot it scores 4.1 out of 5 across more than 3,158 reviews. Our tracker cannot currently read its website, so we do not have live prices for it and do not publish an estimate. Read the full SD Bullion review.
Minted Metal has no financial relationship with either dealer. We do not carry dealer affiliate links, and neither company can pay to influence its rating. Details are in our editorial policy.
Common Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Is SD Bullion cheaper than APMEX?
We cannot say. We do not currently track either dealer's prices because our tracker cannot currently read their sites. Compare the same product on both dealers' product pages before ordering.
Is APMEX more trustworthy than SD Bullion?
Both dealers hold BBB A+ ratings and both have long order histories; SD Bullion says it has shipped more than 2 million orders. APMEX has a longer track record (founded 2000 vs. 2012), but SD Bullion has earned a strong reputation during its decade-plus of operations. Both are legitimate, well-established dealers.
Does SD Bullion have a price match guarantee?
Yes. SD Bullion offers a price match guarantee on identical in-stock products from authorized competitors.
Which dealer is better for rare or collectible coins?
APMEX is the clear choice for rare and collectible coins. With a catalog that includes numismatics, vintage US coins, and limited-edition releases, APMEX carries items that SD Bullion does not stock. SD Bullion focuses almost exclusively on common bullion products.
Compare Every Dealer's Premiums Live
See how APMEX and SD Bullion stack up against eight other dealers on the same products, refreshed throughout the day.
Open the Premium Tracker